The research is blunt: having a transformation office barely predicts success. What it does decides the result. Four tests of a transformation office that works.
The short answer: operating model changes fail more often than they succeed, and setting up a transformation office does not, by itself, change the odds. The office earns its place only when it speeds up decisions, owns the value, makes leaders visible and plans its own exit.
The odds are worse than most boards assume
In McKinsey's research on organisational redesign, fewer than a quarter of redesign efforts succeeded. Forty-four per cent ran out of steam after getting under way, and about a third failed to meet their objectives or improve performance after implementation.
Transformations in general fare little better. In McKinsey's 2021 survey of 1,034 people who had been part of a transformation, fewer than a third said it had improved performance and sustained the improvement. Successful transformations captured, on average, 67% of their potential financial benefit; the rest captured 37%.
Where the value goes is telling. More than half of the value lost, 55%, is lost during and after implementation. Nearly a quarter is lost earlier, when targets are set too low. Twenty per cent is lost after implementation is complete, as the gains fade.
The uncomfortable finding
In McKinsey's 2015 survey of 1,946 executives, having a dedicated organising team, such as a programme or transformation office, ranked last of 24 actions in how closely it correlated with success. The actions at the top were about behaviour, not structure. Transformations where senior managers communicated openly about progress were eight times as likely to succeed. Where senior leaders role-modelled the change, 5.3 times. Where initiative leaders were held accountable in their annual reviews, 3.9 times, and where roles were clear, 3.8 times.
The office is not the answer. What the office does is.
That is not an argument against a transformation office. It is an argument against the kind that collects status reports and adds a layer. The multipliers above are exactly what a good office makes happen, week after week.
Four tests of a transformation office that works
- It speeds up decisions
It keeps a decision log, brings options rather than problems, and measures how long decisions take. If the steering committee is waiting on the office, the office is in the way.
- It owns value, not activity
Benefits are baselined before work starts, owned by named executives and tracked through to the profit and loss account. Milestones met are not the same as value delivered.
- It makes leaders visible
It gives senior leaders a simple, honest view of progress to share, and holds initiative owners to account, which is where the research finds the biggest lift.
- It plans its own exit
Its routines move into business as usual: reviews, measures and decision rights. McKinsey finds that embedding transformation practices into normal processes is one of the habits of successful transformations.
For operating model redesigns: assess first, then design every layer
The same McKinsey redesign research found that companies following all nine of its rules succeeded 86% of the time, and that companies pulling at least two structural, two process and two people levers were three times as likely to succeed as those using fewer. Sixty per cent of executives said they had not spent enough time assessing the organisation before redesigning it.
The lesson is practical: diagnose before you draw boxes, and design structure, process, people, technology, data and governance together, so that no one layer absorbs the cost of the others.
Five questions for your next steering committee
- How long does a typical decision take us, from request to answer?
- Which benefits are baselined, and who owns each one by name?
- What did our senior leaders tell the organisation about progress this month?
- Which initiative owners have the outcomes in their annual objectives?
- Which of the office's routines will still run when the programme ends?
If the answers are slow or vague, the office needs redesigning before the programme does.
Sources
- Aronowitz, De Smet and McGinty, ‘Getting organizational redesign right’, McKinsey Quarterly (June 2015): fewer than a quarter of redesigns succeed; 44% run out of steam; nine rules, 86% success when all are followed; 60% did not spend enough time assessing the organisation first.
- McKinsey, ‘Losing from day one: Why even successful transformations fall short’ (December 2021; 1,034 respondents): fewer than a third improved and sustained performance; 67% vs 37% of potential value captured; 55% of value lost during and after implementation.
- McKinsey, ‘How to beat the transformation odds’ (April 2015; 1,946 executives): a dedicated organising team ranked last of 24 actions; open communication of progress 8.0 times, role-modelling 5.3 times, accountability in annual reviews 3.9 times, clear roles 3.8 times as likely to succeed.
Published by Arkention Consulting on 25 October 2026. Follow Arindam Bhoumick on LinkedIn

